Tap-to-Give Platform Comparison: Which NFC Solution Is Right for Your Church?
With tap-to-give technology transforming church donations, choosing the right platform can save thousands while increasing giving by 300%+. Here's our comprehensive comparison of the top solutions in 2025.
Platform Overview: The Tap-to-Give Landscape
Tap-to-give technology uses NFC (Near Field Communication) to enable instant donations with a simple smartphone tap. As churches increasingly adopt digital giving solutions, four major platforms have emerged as leaders in this space:
Subsplash Tap
All-in-one church platform with integrated NFC giving. Requires full Subsplash ecosystem adoption.
Tithely Tap-to-Give
Popular giving platform with NFC hardware add-on. High setup fees and monthly costs.
Tap Tag
Simple NFC tags for giving. Limited customization and professional appearance.
Tap.Giving
RECOMMENDEDHardware-only solution that works with any existing giving platform. Transparent pricing, no monthly fees.
Detailed Platform Comparison
| Feature | Subsplash Tap | Tithely | Tap Tag | Tap.Giving |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Platform Requirement | Full Subsplash | Tithely Only | Any Platform | Any Platform |
| Setup Fees | Varies | $1,200 | $0 | $0 |
| Monthly Fees | $250+/month | $49-199/month | $0 | $0 |
| Hardware Cost | Bundled | $25/plate | $2-5/tag | $3.50-5.00/plate |
| Professional Design | Yes | Yes | Basic | Yes |
| Customization | Limited | Moderate | Minimal | Full Custom |
| Price Transparency | Contact Required | Partially Hidden | Clear | Fully Transparent |
1. Subsplash Tap: All-in-One Ecosystem
Subsplash Tap is part of Subsplash's comprehensive church platform, offering NFC giving alongside apps, websites, and church management tools. While powerful, it requires full platform adoption.
✅ Pros
- • Integrated church management
- • Single vendor relationship
- • Professional design quality
- • Comprehensive digital solution
❌ Cons
- • Must adopt entire platform
- • High monthly costs ($250+)
- • Platform lock-in
- • No pricing transparency
2. Tithely Tap-to-Give: Established Player
Tithely is a well-known giving platform that added NFC capabilities. Popular among churches but comes with significant setup and ongoing costs.
✅ Pros
- • Established brand reputation
- • Good customer support
- • Professional hardware design
- • Integrated giving platform
❌ Cons
- • $1,200 setup fee
- • $49-199/month ongoing costs
- • $25/plate hardware cost
- • Platform lock-in
3. Tap Tag: Budget Basic Option
Simple NFC tags that redirect to giving pages. While affordable, they lack the professional appearance and functionality of dedicated solutions.
✅ Pros
- • Very low cost ($2-5/tag)
- • No monthly fees
- • Platform flexibility
- • Simple implementation
❌ Cons
- • Unprofessional appearance
- • Limited customization
- • May not inspire confidence
- • Basic functionality
4. Tap.Giving: The Smart Choice
Tap.Giving offers professional NFC hardware that works with any existing giving platform. No monthly fees, transparent pricing, and complete flexibility.
✅ Pros
- • Keep your current platform
- • No monthly fees ever
- • Transparent $3.50-5.00 pricing
- • Professional custom design
- • Complete platform flexibility
❌ Cons
- • Hardware-only solution
- • Requires existing giving platform
5-Year Total Cost Analysis
Let's break down the real costs over 5 years for a church ordering 200 plates:
Subsplash Tap
Tithely
Tap Tag
Tap.Giving
💡 Cost Savings with Tap.Giving
Our Recommendations
❌ Not Recommended
Subsplash Tap
Only if you need complete platform overhaul and budget isn't a concern.
Tithely
High ongoing costs make it poor value for most churches.
⚠️ Use With Caution
Tap Tag
Suitable for very budget-conscious churches, but unprofessional appearance may hurt giving confidence.
✅ Best Choice
Tap.Giving
Professional quality, transparent pricing, platform flexibility, and massive cost savings make this the clear winner.
Ready to Save Thousands While Increasing Giving?
Join hundreds of churches that chose Tap.Giving for transparent pricing and professional quality.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which platform increases giving the most?
All NFC solutions can increase giving by 300%+. The key is ease of use and donor confidence, which professional solutions like Tap.Giving provide while keeping costs low.
Can I switch platforms later?
With Tap.Giving, yes - you own the hardware and can change your giving platform anytime. Platform-specific solutions like Subsplash and Tithely lock you in.
What about security and compliance?
All reputable NFC solutions redirect to secure giving platforms. The security depends on your chosen giving platform, not the NFC hardware itself.
How long does setup take?
With Tap.Giving, setup takes minutes - just place the plates and they redirect to your existing giving page. Platform switches with Subsplash or Tithely can take weeks or months.
What if I'm already using Tithely or another platform?
Perfect! Tap.Giving works with any giving platform including Tithely, Pushpay, Givelify, and more. You can add NFC giving without changing platforms or paying monthly fees.
The Bottom Line
While all tap-to-give solutions can increase church giving, the total cost of ownership varies dramatically. Tap.Giving offers the best combination of professional quality, transparent pricing, and platform flexibility.