Overflow Tap vs Tap.Giving
Compare the real costs: Overflow Tap at $13/disc + $1,200/year + processing fees vs Tap.Giving's transparent one-time cost of $3.50-$5.00 per plate.
Cost Comparison: First Year (200 units)
Overflow Tap
Plus processing fees on all donations
Tap.Giving
in the first year alone!
Plus no ongoing platform fees
Complete Feature Analysis
See exactly what you get with each solution
| Feature | Overflow Tap | Tap.Giving |
|---|---|---|
| Per Disc/Plate Cost | $13.00 | $3.50-$5.00 |
| Annual Platform Fee | $1,200+ | $0 |
| Processing Fees | 2.5% + $0.30 (cards) 0.5% + $0.20 (ACH) |
Via your existing platform |
| Analytics Dashboard | Use your existing platform | |
| Platform Integration | Overflow platform only | Any platform |
| Custom Branding | ||
| Free Shipping | Varies | |
| Volume Discounts | Limited | Up to $1.50 off |
| 5-Year Total Cost (200 units) | $10,600+ | $800 |
5-Year Cost Analysis
See the true long-term cost difference
Overflow Tap (200 units)
Tap.Giving (200 units)
over 5 years!
That's enough to fund major ministry initiatives
Detailed Pros and Cons
Overflow Tap
Advantages
- Real-time updates: Change where discs point without replacing hardware
- Comprehensive analytics: Built-in engagement tracking and metrics
- All-in-one platform: Integrated giving, engagement, and analytics
- Premium finish: High-quality epoxy coating on discs
Disadvantages
- Expensive hardware: $13 per disc vs $3.50-$5.00
- Annual fees: $1,200+ per year platform cost
- Processing fees: Additional 2.5% on all donations
- Platform lock-in: Only works with Overflow platform
- Migration costs: Need to switch entire giving platform
Tap.Giving
Advantages
- Transparent pricing: $3.50-$5.00 per plate, clearly displayed
- No ongoing costs: One-time purchase, no annual fees
- Platform flexibility: Works with Tithely, Subsplash, Planning Center & more
- Volume discounts: Price drops to $3.50 for 400+ plates
- Free shipping: No hidden delivery costs
- Quick implementation: No platform migration required
Trade-offs
- Analytics dependency: Use your existing platform's analytics
- Newer company: Less market presence than established platforms
Which Solution is Right for Your Church?
Choose Overflow Tap If:
- You need real-time content updates without hardware changes
- You want comprehensive analytics and engagement tracking
- You're willing to switch to the Overflow platform
- Budget allows for $3,800+ first year and $1,200+ annually
- You prefer all-in-one integrated solutions
Choose Tap.Giving If:
- You want to minimize costs and maximize ROI
- You're happy with your current giving platform
- You prefer simple, straightforward solutions
- You want transparent pricing without sales calls
- You need to get started quickly without platform migration
Want to compare exact plate quantities and savings? Head to our transparent pricing page and, when you're ready, you can submit your Tap.Giving order online in just a few minutes.
Ready to Save $9,800 Over 5 Years?
Get the same NFC tap-to-give technology without the expensive platform fees and vendor lock-in.
💡 Smart Church Financial Tip
The $9,800 you save with Tap.Giving could fund a youth pastor for 3 months, mission trips, or facility improvements.